Connect with us


Politics of Viola Davis’s Oscar comment about “the only profession that celebrates what it means to live life”



Yesterday, I praised Viola Davis’ Oscar speech for being memorable without being overtly political—for simply talking about her work in a touching and well-written way. Twitter quickly let me know that I missed something. On social media and on conservative news sites, Davis’ speech actually sparked outrage.

Explaining that she believed her mission was to “unearth… the stories of people who dreamed great things but never made those dreams come true, people who fell in love and lost,” Davis said:

I became an artist – and thank God I did – because we are the only profession that celebrates what it means to live life.

This statement became one of the points of discussion of the right Internet after the Oscars ceremony. “Art is beautiful; art enriches; art can connect us to each other,” writes Ben Shapiro. V daily wire. “But the sheer arrogance of declaring that artists are “the only profession that celebrates what it means to live life” is simply amazing. How about doctors? What about stay-at-home mothers who help shape lives rather than pursue their own career interests? How about undertakers? How about if almost everyone in a free market economy gives themselves to others to improve life?

Variations of this sentiment have ricocheted online, with Davis sometimes being misquoted as saying that only “actors” celebrate what it means to live life, or worse, are the only ones who “know” what it means to live life. .

Do people have the right to be offended? Did they say that artists are better than everyone else? If you read her words literally, in the context of her speech, and give her the slightest benefit of doubt, it’s hard to see the backlash against Davis as anything but a symptom of our overblown culture wars.

Everyone “celebrates what it means to live life” in their own way, but for whom can this be the main function of their profession? Artists, definitely. The clergy, perhaps. Doctors Keep life, not to glorify them, and it does not humiliate them if they talk about it. Stay home parents help others, and Davis might even agree that it is more noble, important and necessary than “glorifying” the meaning of life.

Her point was simply that artists have a unique role to play in telling stories about the human experience and that she is glad to be a part of it.

Of course, she could have edited herself to be less controversial, though perhaps less interesting., statements. If she had simply said, “I became an artist—and thank God I did—because we are celebrating what it means to live life,” the complaints might have been more difficult. The word “one” emphasizes the special feature of the artists, but it is also a whistle for anyone who has a strong resentment of Hollywood elitism and condescension. And there has rarely been a better time to express such outrage than now.

On the right, reflective aversion to the entertainment industry has taken on a new dimension under Donald Trump. during Fox and friends after Oscarthe confusion that la la country Wrongly declared “Best Picture” Steve Doucey called “Hollywood got the election wrong, and last night Hollywood got the Oscar wrong.” Guest Tucker Carlson agreed, but added that Moonlight “should have won” because that’s what the moralizing, politically correct establishment wanted. Yes, the Oscars were both a disaster out of touch with reality and a cunningly rigged game.

Donald Trump interpreted the Academy’s failure in his own way: “I think they were so focused on politics that at the end they couldn’t come together,” he said. beardas if the accountant of PricewaterhouseCoopers, who handed Warren Beatty the wrong envelope did so because he cursed too hard at Kimmel, who tweeted the president “are you okay?”

Liberals may moan when Trump attributes a logistical error to his critics. But of course, both sides today see a lot of politics in entertainment: see below. all takes do like Dusi and compare the end of the Oscars to election night.

To many viewers on Sunday, Davis’s speech was remarkable in that she almost went beyond the partisan strife and just spoke passionately about acting. But one word – “only” – was enough to make it a culture war litmus test. Maybe she wanted to argue about the place of art in society, or maybe she just portrayed her profession as she really sees it. In any case, it was a defiant move in an age where artists are increasingly being held to the same standards as candidates for office: they are expected to choose their words not for truth, but for politics.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The black family was reportedly pulled over due to tinted windows. The CPS then took their children.



Two black parents from Georgia are reportedly fighting to get their five children back from Tennessee. The saga began when they were pulled over for tinted windows and arrested for possession of a small amount of marijuana more than a month ago.

Bianca Claiborne and Deonte Williams were on their way to a funeral in Chicago on February 17 when Tennessee Highway Patrol pulled them over for being “dark in color”.[ed windows] and driving in the left lane without active overtaking”, according to Lookouta non-profit news organization that broke history and spoke to the family.

According to Tennessee Lookout, after the car was pulled over, police found a joint and a small amount of marijuana in the bag, less than five grams of marijuana in total. The police charged Williams with a misdemeanor and arrested him, while Claiborne was charged.

But just six hours later, Claiborne, who was not arrested, reportedly had her five children taken from her and placed in state custody after the State Department of Children’s Affairs requested and received an emergency order from a judge. Their youngest child is a four-month-old boy who is still breastfed, Claiborne told Tennessee Lookout. The remaining children are aged 2 to 7 years.

The state reportedly accused the family of putting their children in danger in court documents obtained by Lookout.

Williams told Tennessee Lookout that this is a lie and that he believes the state “kidnapped” his children. Claiborne told Lookout her health has been affected, including a trip to the emergency room due to a panic attack last weekend, which she attributes to the anguish of separation from her children.

A lawyer representing the family said their ordeal “shocks the conscience”.

“I just have to believe that if my clients looked different or had a different background they would just be given a link and told you just keep these things away from kids while you are in this state and they would be on his. way,” Nashville lawyer Jamaal Boykin told Tennessee Lookout.

The Department of Children’s Affairs told VICE News in a statement that state anonymity laws prevent them from commenting on active cases and suggested that “anyone who releases the contents of a minor’s petition is breaking the law.” However, DCS said the Coffee County Judge was responsible for the decision to place Williams and Claiborne’s children in state custody.

“DCS and law enforcement are following evidence collection protocol,” a spokesperson for VICE News said via email. “These findings are then presented to the court. In this case, the evidence led the court to place the children in DCS custody.”

A spokesman for the Tennessee Highway Patrol told VICE News in a statement that “criminal investigations and prosecutions are ongoing and the District Attorney’s office serving Coffee County has claimed the privilege of not releasing documents at this time,” citing Criminal Justice Rules in Tennessee Courts.

Tennessee’s foster care system has long been recognized as one of the most dysfunctional in the nation. In July 2021, seven children in state custody spent the night at the DCS office in Nashville, including several children who slept on the floor. according to video obtained by Tennessee Lookout at the time.

And last year, the Tennessee Commission on Children and Youth says the report that from 2016 to 2020, the state had the highest rate of foster care instability in the nation, defined as three or more placements in the first year of detention. At the time, more than 33 percent of cases in Tennessee met this definition, compared to a national average of 14 percent. (Supreme Senator of Tennessee Republican Party filed a bill to abolish the Commission for Children and Youth.)

Democratic State Senator London Lamar said at a press conference on Thursday that the justice system is “absolutely inadequate [the] children on charges of misdemeanor.

“It’s absolutely ridiculous when marijuana is legal in about half the states in the country, and a black family has five children taken away and placed in a DCS that does a poor job of caring for the children they already have.” Lamar said Thursday. “And they will not return their children to them on charges of wrongdoing.”

Want the best VICE news straight to your inbox? Sign here.

Continue Reading


Mike Pence Defends Recording in Trump Admin to ABC Anchor: ‘I Know It’s Annoying’ to National Media



Former Vice President Mike Pence addressed national media on Sunday during an interview with ABC’s Jonathan Karl and said that despite it being “annoying” to members of the media, he was “proud” of the four years he spent with the former president. Donald. Trump.

Carl asked Pence if Trump was a “man of his word.”

“I am very proud of the track record of the Trump administration and Pence,” Pence replied. “On issue after issue, we have kept our word to the American people. Whether it’s rebuilding the military, cutting taxes, freeing up American energy, securing the border, appointing conservative judges, pro-life judges, it’s given us a fresh start for life.”

“One problem after another,” he continued. “I saw the president keep his word to the American people, and I was proud to have been by his side for four years. And I know this annoys some people in the national media, John, but as I wrote in my book, I’m incredibly proud of our track record in administration. It didn’t end well, it ended in controversy.”


Carl insisted that he was not asking about Trump’s track record, but about “the man.”

Former VP Mike Pence is dating ABC’s Jonathan Karl. (Screenshot/ABC/ThisWeek)

“I’m not asking you about the record, I’m asking about the person,” Carl said. “Another time you said, ‘I always tell people that to know President Trump is to know someone whose word is his bond.’ I mean, this is someone who, as you admitted in your book, lied to the American people about what you told them about January 6th, that you can’t do this to them. This is just one of many, many, many. examples. don’t think to still know President Trump to know his word is his commitment. Again, not an administration dossier, Donald Trump is the man.”

Pence said he was “deeply disappointed” with Trump’s words on Jan. 6 and days before, and said he spoke with Trump in the week following the Capitol riots.

“I was very direct with him about my experience, my view of him and my belief that I had done my duty and we parted amicably and respectfully, but in the following months he returned to the same rhetoric he used before January 6th rhetoric that continues to this day, and so we parted ways, and I continue to be disappointed in the fact that the president did not see a clear path to know that, by the grace of God, we did our duty that day, ” – he said.

The former vice president also told Carl that history will “hold Trump accountable” for Jan. 6.

Former Vice President Mike Pence speaks at the Calvin Coolidge Foundation Conference at the Library of Congress on February 16, 2023 in Washington, DC.  (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Former Vice President Mike Pence speaks at the Calvin Coolidge Foundation Conference at the Library of Congress on February 16, 2023 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images) (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Mike Pence mourns the collapse of relations with Trump and fondly remembers the time in the White House

On Thursday, Pence said he disagreed with Trump and the governor. Ron DeSantis, Florida, Ukraine.

“Republicans must be clear that we understand that America is the arsenal of democracy…we must continue to give the brave Ukrainian military the support they need to push Russia off their sovereign soil,” Pence said.

Former US President Donald Trump, along with former US Vice President Mike Pence, arrives for a

Former US President Donald Trump, along with former US Vice President Mike Pence, arrives for a “Make America Great Again” rally at Cherry Capital Airport in Traverse City, Michigan on November 2, 2020. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski/AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP) via Getty Images) ((Photo by Brendan Smialowski/AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP via Getty Images))


“Let me be clear: the war in Ukraine is not a territorial dispute. This is a Russian invasion,” Pence said, referring to DeSantis’ comments.

DeSantis told Fox News’ Tucker Carlson that involvement in the “territorial dispute between Ukraine and Russia” is not a “vital” American national interest.

Continue Reading


Copyright © 2023 News Logics Media.